More Discussions for this daf
1. Go'el ha'Dam in an Ir Miklat? 2. The Go'el ha'Dam and Eidim Zomemim 3. Rotze'ach In Mid-Air Over the Ir Miklat
DAF DISCUSSIONS - MAKOS 12

Chaim Harpaz asks:

Can the Go'el ha'Dam kill the Rotzeiach if the Rotzaiach is in the air space above the Ir Miklat?

Chaim Harpaz, Norfolk, VA

The Kollel replies:

It seems to me that if the Go'el ha'Dam kills the Rotze'ach when he is in the airspace above the Ir Miklat, the Goel ha'Dam would not be put to death.

This is because the Gemara states (three lines from the bottom of 12a) that concerning Ir Miklat it all depends on "Dirah" -- where one resides. Even though the root of the tree is inside the city of refuge, since the spreading leaves of the tree are outside the city, we say that the Rotze'ach is not considered as being inside the Ir Miklat, because under the leaves is a more suitable place for living than the roots of the tree.

Similarly, we can say that "up in the air" is not a place where one can live, so the Rotze'ach is not considered to be inside the city. (See also Ayeles ha'Shachar.)

Kol Tuv,

Dovid Bloom