More Discussions for this daf
1. Redeem a first born; remove seven heads 2. letters of the Torah 3. A few questions
4. Serving one's parents 5. Letters, words, and verses in the Torah 6. Talmud Bavli and learning Tanach
7. The Middle of Tehilim 8. Pidyon Ha'Ben 9. Zevulun ben Dan
10. 600,000 Letters in the Torah 11. מאי כל מצות האב על הבן אילימא כל מצותא דמיחייב אבא למיעבד לבריה נשים חייבות 12. Letra Central da Torah - Central Letter of Torah
13. Shmuel regarding Chinuch 14. Obligation to teach child to swim 15. Number of verses in the Torah
16. Kol Mizwot ha'Av Al ha'Ben - Shuv? 17. Lefichach 18. Insights Source
19. Vav of Gachon 20. Vav of Gachon 21. כל מצוות האב על הבן
22. לפיכך
DAF DISCUSSIONS - KIDUSHIN 30

Yair Aaron asks:

why cant you learn from cul bechor banecha that a daughter does not have to redeem herself?

Yair Aaron, Bk New York

The Kollel replies:

Shalom R' Aaron!

Great to hear from you.

Excellent question! It seems that Rashi (29a DH Ihi) addresses this important issue. Rashi tells us that from the words "Bechor Banecha" alone, we would only be able establish that a father does not have to redeem his daughter. Theoretically, however, as you noted, there may still exist an obligation upon the daughter to redeem herself. The rationale for this would be two-fold. First, the Mitzvah of Pidyon is not considered bound by time, and therefore women ought to be Chayav. And secondly, the interpretation of the word "Tifdeh" as "Tipadeh", indicates that not only the father has an obligation to redeem his children, but also that the children -- after they grow older -- bear the responsibility to arrange their own Pidyon. Therefore, it is necessary to learn the daughter's exemption based on the rule "Kol she'Acherim Metzuvim Lif'Doso" etc.

Warmest regards,

Yishai Rasowsky