More Discussions for this daf
1. Mehalech k'Omed 2. Ben Azai 3. Ramban and Meleches Machsheves
4. The hand of a person is considered 4 by 4 5. water on water 6. Akirah and Hanachah
7. Akirah from 4 x 4 8. Reshus Ha'Yachid Mekureh 9. Akirah on Water
10. עקירה והנחה 11. רש״י ד״ה דרך סטיו ורש״י דף ז' ד״ה בין העמודים

Moshe Deutsch asks:

If Rebbe is only Mechayev in a RHY M'Kureh, so we have to say that the picture of the case is that he threw the object through the covered RHY where there were open windows on both sides it went (good shot) thru both open windows..

If this is the case, then why do I care that the RHY is considerd filled up to the ceiling or not? Even if it were not considered filled up to the ceiling, wouldnt it still be considered like it stopped in the RHY and started again giving him two chiyuvim?

Moshe Deutsch, Flushing, New York

The Kollel replies:

No, it would not be considered like it stopped and started again unless it physically came to rest (or unless we say Kelutah etc.). One is not guilty of Hotza'ah on Shabbos unless he makes an Akirah and Hanachah, and flying through a Reshus is not considered Akirah or Hanachah.

Best regards,

Mordecai Kornfeld

Kollel Iyun Hadaf