More Discussions for this daf
1. Why the woman says Amen, Amen 2. Rav Hamnuna 3. Bereirah and Dichuy
4. u'Tehorah Hi 5. אמן שלא אטמא 6. שירטוט אחר כתיבה
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SOTAH 18

Aaron Shemtob asks:

Shalom rabbi

Hope all is well. The Gemarah says that a Shevuat Alah is where the Kohen says:

Mashbiani Alayich she'Lo Nitmeis v'Im Nitmeis Yavo'u Bich

My question is did the woman repeat the swear of the Kohen and say Ani Mashbiah etc. or did she just answer Amen to him? Because really v'Hishbia is binyan Hifil which is causative meaning he caused her to swear implying that she actually uttered the swear.

Thank you, miss you

Aaron

The Kollel replies:

Shalom Aaron,

Nice question! No, the woman does not have to repeat the whole thing. She just answers "Amen" twice in a language that she understands (1). This counts as her acceptance of the oath and accompanying curse, so it is legitimate to use the term "Mashbi'ah," for instance.

Best regards,

Yishai Rasowsky