More Discussions for this daf
1. Do not list modesty, for I ("Ana") am still alive 2. Ongoing creation 3. Rebbi
4. Siege of Hurkanus and Aristobulus
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SOTAH 49

Daniel Gray asked:

I remember hearing that the Vilna Gaon has a pshat on the last lines where someone comments that "Anavah" wasn't "Battel", as his existence shows "Haeika anah". Any idea where to find it?

Thanks and Good Shabbos, Daniel Gray, CPA Ernst & Young e-mail: daniel.gray@ca.eyi.com

The Kollel replies:

The Divrei Eliyahu (Maseches Sotah) quotes a Sefer (from 1910) that claims "it is said in the name of the Vilna Gaon" that the word "Ana" does not refer to Rav Yosef (the one who made the statement) but to an Amora by the name of Rav Ana, who is mentioned in the Yerushalmi a number of times.

Presumably, Rav Nachman was discussing the same Rav Ana.

(We wrote some comments of our own on Rav Yosef's statements in the Insights to the Daf.)

Be well, Mordecai

Yitzchak Zirkind comments:

See Margoliyas Hayam Sanhedrin 98b Ois 17.

Kol Tuv,

Yitzchok Zirkind