More Discussions for this daf
1. The statement of Rebbi Chanina mi'Sura 2. Zivugim 3. sotah
4. Second Marriage 5. Kinuy b'Zman ha'Zeh 6. Rashi DH Makneh Lah Al Pi Shenayim
7. One Ed by Sotah Vadai 8. What if Husband Dies? 9. Shmuel bar Rav Yitzach amar Resh Lokish
10. Kinui Without Eidim 11. Laws of Sotah 12. Zivug Rishon and Zivug Sheni
13. Finding the right one 14. Sotah 15. Zivug Rishon and Sheni
16. Different factors for a Sotah 17. V'Ed Ein Bah 18. 7 Nations
19. נאמנות הבעל לטומאה
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SOTAH 2

Aron Mendelovitz asks:

Hi. On Daf 2a, it says that [after proper kinui and stira] one aid is believed to say he saw tumah take place and the wife doesnt get to drink and goes out without her kesuba. being that kesuba is mamonis why would one aid be believed? on the sotah side I understand, but why on the money side (kesubah)?

Thank you!

Aron Mendelovitz, New York, USA

The Kollel replies:

The Gemara below (3a) cites Tana d'Vei Rebbi Yishmael that the Torah believed one Ed for Sotah because there was Kinuy and Stirah beforehand, so one witness who saw the Tum'ah is sufficient to make "Raglayim l'Davar," a strong reason to believe, that she committed the offense. The combination of the fact that she was warned in advance, and then was secluded with the suspect, is enough to enable the Torah to rely on one witness to be sure that it happened, and therefore she loses money as well.

Kol Tuv,

Dovid Bloom