More Discussions for this daf
1. Kinuy of a Katan 2. Difference between R. Yonoson and R. Yoshiya 3. Unnecessary Mishnah?
4. A Nesinah to a Yisrael 5. d'Rabanan overriding a d'Oraisa 6. Definition of a Saris
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SOTAH 24

Pesach Feldman asked:

Yibum of a ben Tesha - the Ramban (Yevamos 51B) says that it makes her a full Eshes Ish for everything except Misah, even to become Asur through Znus.

I am almost certain that there is no Drasha about a Katan making Kinuy in this entire Maseches. On 27A, there is a Drasha Ish-Ish to include Cheresh, Shoteh and Shuamum that Beis Din warns his wife - why is Katan omitted?

By the Sugyos of Gilgul Shvua (Kedushin 27...)- why doesn't the Gemara say that Kenusah is a wife of a Ben Tesha (and this is the source of Gilgul)?! (There should be Gilgul, since she becomes Asur through Znus).

This seems to me a proof that Yibum of a Ben Tesha is d'Rabanan, or (as the Ra'avad) mid'Oraisa, but she cannot become Asur through Znus.

Pesach Feldman

The Kollel replies:

The Pashtus of the Mishnah in Yevamos 96b and the Gemara there is that it is mid'Rabanan. See Tosfos Kidushin 19a DH u'mid'Oraisa.

Dov Zupnik