More Discussions for this daf
1. The Beraisa which lists the Toldos 2. Toldah of Betzirah 3. Who needs a verse if there is a Halachah
4. Clearing rocks to plant grass 5. Idur 6. Zorayah
7. Charishah 8. תוד"ה אין דנין
DAF DISCUSSIONS - MOED KATAN 3

Jeremy Caplan asked:

In Moed Katan (3A) it says on the third line "Michdei, Zemira BiChlal Zeriyah". This seems difficult to me because we are attempting to give pshat in the mishnah that sowing is allowed on Sheviis. So isn't this answer just making things worse. This answer basically says Mefurash that sowing is Asur on Sheviis!

Jeremy Caplan, Edison, NJ USA

The Kollel replies:

First of all, the Gemara is discussing the first line in the Mishnah, that one is permitted to water the field. This is not stated in the Torah as a prohibited action, and therefore is permitted. When the Gemara says, "Michdi etc.," it is merely providing the source for the previous statement that Toldos are not included. It is not referring to our Mishnah.

All the best,

Yaakov Montrose