More Discussions for this daf
1. Cities that are near walled cities 2. 13 Adar 3. Questions
4. Gezeirah Shaveh must be handed down 5. Purim in Har Nof 6. Villagers reading the Megilah early on market days
7. Reading the Megilah on the 15th of Adar 8. Reading the Megilah 9. When the Megilah may be read on the 11th, 12th, and 13th
10. "Mentazpach" Tzofim Amarum 11. The end-letters MeNaTZPaCH 12. Rebbi Yehudah
13. Women Who Reside in the Kefarim 14. Heichan Remizah? 15. Rebbi Yehoshua ben Korchah argues with Rebbi Akiva?
16. End Letters 17. Tosfos 18. Rabbi Yehoshua Ben Korcha's Rebbe
19. Gezeirah Shavah of Perazi 20. Issues of Beis Din 21. Menatzpa"Ch
22. Various Questions 23. Ta'anis Esther in villages 24. Limiting the reading of the Megillah to the 14th
25. Walled city 26. רש״י ד״ה כדכתיב להיות עושים 27. תענית אסתר בכפרים
DAF DISCUSSIONS - MEGILAH 2

Mordechai asked:

(a) How does R' Shmuel bar Nachmeini learn out that future generations should read the megillah? Since he uses possuk "Ka'Yamim..." to teach the extra 2 days, he no longer can use that possuk. And if it were written explictly in Megillah that future generations should read, why then would Rav Sh'man bar Aba need to use possuk "Ka'Yamim to teach"

(b) Who are R' Eliezer b' Rebbi Yossi and R Menachem b Rebbi Yossi. Did they also write Stam Mishna's and are they R' Akiva's students? Could you clarify this?

I hope you don't mind me asking questions. I am very diligent and am reading all your material and go slow and absorb everything you write down. The only way to learn is to ask. And it's not easy asking local Rabbis' either because they aren't learning subject and it takes time for them just to learn daf well to see what's going on or time requirements, but I know that you are concentrating on the daf yomi. I want to send in a donation, do you take credit card?

Thanks again.

Mordechai, USA

The Kollel replies:

(a) He learns it from the same place that everyone else learns it: "Li'hyos Osim etc.." and we compare Zechirah (reading the Megilah) to Asiyah (the fact that we have a Seudah, etc., see 2b).

(b) The Bereishis Rabah indeed identifies Rebbi Eliezer and Rebbi Menachem as two of the sons of Rebbi Yosi.R' Menachem's opinion appears in authorless Mishnayos/Beraisos enough (i.e. Megilah 26a, Kesuvos 101b) to call him "Rebbi Menachem Stimtai" -- "Rebbi Menachem (whose opinion is in) Stam (Mishnayos/Beraisos)" (see Seder Hadoros under "Rebbi Menachem").

Kol Tuv,

Yaakov Montrose