More Discussions for this daf
1. Intentionally not reciting Birkat ha'Mazon where one eats 2. Two questions 3. Havdalah and Women
4. Mekor in Rashi 5. Berachos 053: Amen 6. Machlokes Tana'im
7. Customs for concluding the meal 8. Mayim Acharonim 9. Answering Amen to a child's blessing
10. Making blessing on flame of gentiles 11. Gezundheit 12. Scents of AZ, Alef & Ayin, the Havdalah flame
13. "They" give him reward 14. The color of a flame 15. Rabba bar bar Chana forgetting to say Birkas Hamazon
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BERACHOS 53

Chaim Ozer Shulman asks:

Yatza Mimikomo ViLo Birech See Shulchan Aruch 184:A, Rema, that according to Beis Shamai who holds that even Bishogeg Yachzor Limikomo, by Meizid then even "Bidieved Lo Yatza." What is the source in the Gemama for this?

chaim ozer shulman

The Kollel replies:

Excellent question.

The BACH suggests the following answer: The Gemara relates the story of the two talmidim, one who did "b'Meizid" like Beis Hillel. That tells us that there is an argument between Beis hShamai and Beis Hillel even in the case of Meized. Sine Beis Hillel holds that b'Meizid he must go back only l'Chatchilah, Beis Shamai must hold that b'Meizid one is not even Yotzei b'Di'eved. See also Biur ha'Gra ibid. DH v'Im.

TAZ suggests another approach.

BE well