More Discussions for this daf
1. The Obligation Of Berachah Rishonah 2. Basis for berachos 3. Neta Revai
4. Chutz Min ha'Yayin 5. A Sevara for Berachos 6. First Tosfos DH Keitzad
7. wine and olive oil 8. Kal VaChomer - Min HaTorah or Not? 9. "Em" - Mother is Klal Yisrael
10. Is logic as strong as a Biblical edict? 11. Rebbi Yehudah's opinion, and ha'Gagen/ha'Gefen 12. Kavanah For Tefilah
13. Tosfos DH Keitzad 14. Derech Eretz 15. The ideal in Torah learning
16. Fasting for a bad dream 17. The source for reciting Berachos 18. Special blessings for wine and bread
19. harmful effects of olive oil 20. The blessing for olive oil 21. Shirah of the Levi'im
22. ברכת על הגפן
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BERACHOS 35

Yitzi Loewy asked:

Tosfos brings down Rav Chaim Cohen who explains that the reason we can't learn neter reva out from the g"s by maaser sheni is because then we would only know that pidyon applies in years 1,2,4,5 but not in 3 and 6. What is Rav Chaim Cohen's, svara the reason there's no pidyon is because there is no maaser sheni but if there was maaser sheni then there would be pidyon so we still should be able to learn it out from maaser sheni?

Yitzi Loewy, USA

The Kollel replies:

Dear Yitzi

Hello there and thanks for your question. I think that Tosfos means to say that in the years three and six respectively, Revai would not be Kodesh just as there is no obligation to separate Ma'aser Sheni during those years and thus there is no need to redeem it before eating it.

All the best.

Y. Landy