More Discussions for this daf
1. The Wife Of The Chasid 2. Doresh El ha'Meisim 3. POINT BY POINT OUTLINES OF THE YERUSHALMI
4. Berachos 018b Doresh El ha'Meisim 5. Traveling with a Torah scroll 6. Halachos of Honoring the Dead.
7. Shmuel's Father and Dumah 8. How Did People Learn in the Time of the Gemara? 9. Ma'aseh of the Shtei Ruchos- Lashon Hara?
10. Hidden Zuz 11. Beis Kevaros 12. אלמא ידעי
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BERACHOS 18

Dovid Kent asks:

On this daf there is a story about the children of Rav Chiya who were pained because they forgot their learning when going out to work on their family fields (that's the way I understand it).

How did they learn after the Mishnoyos were written down? Memory, scrolls? If it was memory they sure had a lot to remember. How did people learn?

Dovid Kent, Kew Garden Hills, NY 11367

The Kollel replies:

Dear Dovid,

(a) Originally, Torah she'Ba'al Peh was learned totally by memory, with countless reviews. (If Hash-m so commanded, it is humanly possible to remember it!)

(b) After the Mishnayos were written down (see Bava Metzia 33b and Rashi DH b'Yemei Rebbi) for the reason) and became easier to learn, the Gemara was still learned by memory but the Mishnayos were preserved in scrolls. For example, Rebbi Chiya wrote and publicized Mishnayos scrolls; see Bava Metzia 85b.

All the best,

Reuven Weiner