More Discussions for this daf
1. Starting off with the wrong Berachah 2. Teshuvah 3. Midas Yom ba'Lailah
4. Only 3 "Fathers" 5. Yotzer Ohr 6. bread vs. dates
7. Tosfos 8. When one is in Doubt about Blessings 9. Nations being judged
10. Answering Missionaries 11. divine name in blessings 12. Mistaken Berachah
13. Kavanah during Berachos 14. טעה בברכה 15. רש״י ד״ה אלא אי אמרת
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BERACHOS 12

Aryeh Rosen asked:

What is it about dates that it has a 'halachic' statis of something that sustains, that even if one were to make 'HaMotzi' on a date he would still be yotzai his 'chiyuv', 'b'dieved'?

The work of this esteemed Kollel has helped many of our bochurim in the Yeshiva Gedola of Greater Washington (Silver Spring) Thank You Again!

Aryeh Rosen, Silver Spring MD USA

The Kollel replies:

First of all, please note that the Gemara is not speaking about Hamotzi. Rather, it is discussing reciting Birkas ha'Mazon as opposed to Al ha'Etz v'Al Pri ha'Etz. The Rosh writes that even with the first Berachah of Birkas ha'Mazon you are Yotzei.

The reason that dates are considered "Meizin" is because one can eat them for his main nourishment, like bread. The same cannot be said for the other six of the seven Minim.

Thank you and best wishes,

D. Zupnik