More Discussions for this daf
1. Starting off with the wrong Berachah 2. Teshuvah 3. Midas Yom ba'Lailah
4. Only 3 "Fathers" 5. bread vs. dates 6. Tosfos
7. When one is in Doubt about Blessings 8. Nations being judged 9. Answering Missionaries
10. divine name in blessings 11. Mistaken Berachah 12. Kavanah during Berachos
13. טעה בברכה
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BERACHOS 12

Yeshayahu Schmidt asks:

Dear R. Kornfeld,

G'mar Tov. I hope all is well for now and for next year. Is there a difference, maybe, between Rashi - DH Pasach B'dshichra: a"m shehakol (as opposed to a"m shechar)...*nizkar* shehu yayin, and Tos. D"H Pasach - *Havin* shehaya shechar.

G'mar chatimah tovah,

Yeshayahu Schmidt

The Kollel replies:

Yeshayahu,

Hi! Sorry for taking so long to respond. I'm catching up now on the readers' questions. Feel free to ask more in the future -- in fact, I always enjoy your He'oros.

About the Rashi and tosfos, that's a very interesting observation. There certainly is room to argue that there is a difference between the two opinions, as you suggest. (However, the Rashba quotes Rashi with a wording similar to that of Tosfos.)

Be well,

-Rabbi Kornfeld