More Discussions for this daf
1. Dolphinin, Bnei Yama 2. Dolphins/Mermaids 3. Why a cat?
4. Sirenas 5. Eggs Laid At Twilight
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BECHOROS 8

Rephael Anzarouth asked:

BS"D

Shalom.

The snake is cursed 7 times more than the donkey, because the donkey was cursed 7 times more than the shortest chayah (cat-52 days).

Opinion #2 in daf 8b says the cat was chosen in order to maximize the ratio of 7, which is a punishment for the snake. If this is true, why Hash-m chose the cat (52 days)? He should have chosen an arnevet or a shafan or a mouse whose gestation (20-30 days) is certainly shorter than a cat's. Thus, the opinion #2 in Bechorot 8b which says that Hash-m intended to maximize its punishment seems not plausible. How can we explain it?

Yasher koach and Todah Rabbah!

Rephael Anzarouth

The Kollel replies:

Dear Rephael:

The Gemara needs the shortest Chayah, not Behemah. It seems Arnevet and Shafan (and Gamal!) are in the Behemah category. See Kil'ayim 8:6 and in Tosfos Anshei Shem there concerning Chazir. A mouse is Achbar which is a third category called Sheretz and thus cannot be called a Chayah either.

All the best,

Reuven Weiner