More Discussions for this daf
1. Pesach on Monday 2. Argument between Rebbi Simon and Rebbi Yehudah 3. Teaching a trade is a Mitzvah
4. Maybe He Will Slaughter a Little Bird 5. Making a Wound on Shabbos 6. Dam Mifkad Pakid
7. Seems like a redundancy 8. הקדמת נישואין לאבל מחמת אונס 9. סיבת אין בעילה במוצ"ש
10. מקלקל אצל הפתח
DAF DISCUSSIONS - KESUVOS 5

Yehuda Sperling asked:

We say if Yom Kippur is on Monday he might come to shecht a little bird.Its Shabbos, AND, its right before Yom Kippur, do we really think he will come to be Mechalel Shabbos?

yehuda sperling, brooklyn,ny

The Kollel replies:

Abaye is saying merely that according to the logic being presented by Rebbi Zeira -- that we push off getting married due to this possibility which is a need for after Shabbos -- we similarly should make sure that Yom Kippur does not fall on Monday but rather on Tuesday. (The Gemara promptly differentiates between this case and Rebbi Zeira's case.)

If you are bothered because this is right before Yom Kippur and thus how would anyone come to transgress the prohibition against doing Melachah on Shabbos, the answer is that Gezeiros are generally made even when people are in a holy time or situation. For example, in his famous comment, the Moshav Zekenim writes that the Torah prohibited a Kohen Gadol from marrying a widow because he might Daven for a married woman's husband to die when he is in the Kodesh ha'Kodashim on Yom Kippur, in order that he be able to marry her. It certainly is possible (within the realm of the Gezeiros of Chazal) that a person will have a very busy schedule and be extremely preoccupied and end up slaughtering on Shabbos.

All the best,

Yaakov Montrose