hebrew
1)

What was Moshe's question? We often find multiple warnings!

1.

Rashi: He claimed that it was unnecessary to warn Yisrael not to ascend Har Sinai, since they had been already prohibited from doing so since three days. 1

2.

Rashbam: He was asking Hashem whether, having initially prohibited the people from ascending the mountain, He was now adding a prohibition to break their ranks and to move a little closer, even without ascending the mounting.

3.

Da'as Zekenim (21), Hadar Zekenim (21), Rosh (21): Moshe had not warned Yisrael about the Mitzvah of Hagbalah, only about separating [from their wives]. Hashem said that it is more important to warn about Hagbalah, which is punishable by death. Moshe answered, you warned us, including me and Aharon; we will be with them 2 , and warn them not to ascend! Hashem responded, you and Aharon will ascend more than them; you will not be with them to warn them then, so warn them now.

4.

Moshav Zekenim: Moshe asked, am I included in the Am, who are forbidden to ascend the mountain?

5.

Divrei Eliyahu: Moshe said, you warned us, including me and Aharon, not to ascend. Surely the people will not ascend! Hashem responded, you and Aharon will ascend


1

See Rashbam's objections, the first of which Rashi himself negates in the following Pasuk.

2

Rosh: Moshe asked in order to learn how far he will ascend; his question assumed that he will be like everyone else.

Chumash: Perek: Pasuk:
Month: Day: Year:
Month: Day: Year:

KIH Logo
D.A.F. Home Page
Sponsorships & Donations Readers' Feedback Mailing Lists Talmud Archives Ask the Kollel Dafyomi Weblinks Dafyomi Calendar Other Yomi calendars