It depends on whether the amount of money written in the Kesuvah in front of us is the regular amount.
Machlokes between Answers A and B.
Machlokes between Answers A and C.
A person found a Shtar among other Shtaros, which he is not sure if it was already paid; what should he do?
He should give it to the Malveh.
He should give it to the Loveh.
He should give it to whoever it makes more sense that it belongs to him.
He should give it to whoever brings Aidim that he gave the Shtar to this person to watch.
Yehei Munach Ad Sheyavo Eliyahu.
How does a person who found a bundle of three Shtaros announce the Aveidah?
“I found three items,” and the Siman that the person will give is that they are Shatros.
“I found Shtaros,” and the Siman that the person will give is that there are three of them.
“I found three Shtaros,” and the Siman that the person will give is describing something about them.
“I found something,” and the Siman is what is the item, even without the exact number.
Any way of announcing it is fine.
A person finds a bundle of three Shtaros, all that have one Malveh’s name, and three different Lovehs; what does he do?
He should give every Shtar back to the Loveh whose name appears on it, because maybe they already repaid.
He should give every Shtar back to the Loveh whose name appears on it, because maybe the Sofer wrote them for each Loveh, but the Lovehs didn’t yet use them to borrow money.
He should give all three Shtaros back to the Malveh whose name appears on them.
Since we are unsure if the Shtaros were paid, Yehei Munach Ad Sheyavo Eliyahu. He should give each Shtar back to whoever brings Aidim that its his.
Answers A and B.
A person found a Shover among other his Shtaros saying that Yosef ben Shimon paid his Chov. What should be done if there are two people of this name in town, both claiming that it is his?
They are both Potur from paying, because each one has a Taina that its his.
Since the Shtar is inconclusive, it can't serve as a Rayah to either person.
Each person must pay half.
Its Mestaver that the Shover belongs to the person who borrowed money earlier, because he probably paid first, also.