The Nigzal gives the Gazlan the Sadeh after the Gazlan had sold it. Who gets the Sadeh?
The buyer keeps it, because he now has the Zechus to sell the Sadeh (why should he require a new Kinyan).
The buyer keeps it; the Gazlan got the Sadeh so he could complete the sale.
The Gazlan can take it back; since there is no Svora of Tircha by Matanah, we don’t say that the Gazlan’s reason to get the Sadeh was so he could complete the sale.
Machlokes between Answers B and C.
Machlokes between Answers A and B.
Until when do we say that Ganav was Torei’ach to buy the Sadeh in order that it will stay by the Lokeyach?
Until Beis Din takes the Sadeh from the Lokeyach and brings the Gazlan to Din.
Until Beis Din makes the Ganav pay, by giving the Lokeyach a Shtar allowing to take any Sadeh he wants.
Until the Lokeyach actually finds an appropriate Sadeh to collect his debt.
Machlokes between Answers A and C.
Machlokes between Answers A, B, and C.
One who is Mekadeish an Ishah for after she will be Megayer; is it a Kiddushin?
Yes; Adam Makneh Davar Shelo Bah L’Olam.
Yes; because she has the ability to be Megayer.
No; Ain Adam Makeh Davar Shelo Bah L’Olam.
Machlokes between Answers A and C.
Machlokes between Answers B and C.
One who received a Sadeh as payment for a debt, and then the Loveh gets money to pay. Need he take the cash and return the Sadeh?
Yes; the Torah says V’Aseesa HaYashar V’HaTov.
Yes; the Torah says Tzeddek Tzeddek Tirdof.
Yes; the Torah says V’Haderech Asher Yelchu Bo.
No; the deal has been done.
No, he was already Meya’eish on the Sadeh.
What is a case where a person wouldn’t tear up a Shtar after he repaid the debt?
The Loveh wants to save the Shtar to use it for another loan.
When the Malveh paid for the Shtar, and the Loveh hasn’t yet repaid the Malveh for the service.