Beis Din confiscates the Talis — Yeheh Munach Ad Sheyuvo Eliyahu.
What does being “Motzei” an object mean?
Seeing the object.
Actually picking the object up.
“Metziya” means “seeing” when used by the Torah, and means “picking up” when used by people.
“Metziya” means “picking up” when used by the Torah, and means “seeing” when used by people.
Machlokes between answers A and B.
Rav Simi bar Ashi explains that our Mishna discusses
Metzia
Mekach U’Memkar.
Chenvani Al Pinkaso (A storekeeper’s ledger).
Mekach U’Memkar and Chenvani Al Pinkaso (A storekeeper’s ledger).
Metzia and Mekach U’Memkar.
The Rabanan hold that Mamon Hamutal Besafeik is:
Divided without a Shevua.
Divided with a Shevua.
Hamotzi Meichaveiro Alav Haraya.
Machlokes between answers A and B.
Machlokes between answers A and C.
It appears that our Mishna is not like Sumchus because:
Sumchus says to divide disputed money without a Shevua and our Mishna says divide it with a Shevua.
Sumchus says to Hamotzi Meichaveiro Alav Haraya on disputed money and our Mishna says divide it with a Shevua.
Sumchus says to divide disputed money even when the disputants are not grasping it, and our Mishna says to divide it only because they are grasping it.
Sumchus appears to only be discussing a cow, and our Mishna appears to only be discussing a Talis.