Why did אביי rule רבא בר שרשום had to return the land belonging to orphans?
He felt they owed no further money.
מיגו doesn't help by orphans.
His מיגו was wrong.
Rabbonim are kept to a higher standard.
Machlokes B&D.
A relative died leaving a date-palm, Rav Idi bar Avin claimed that he was the closest relation. Another came claiming to be closer and grabbed the tree. In the end the man gave up his claim. Must he return fruits retroactively?
Yes.
No.
Only here as Rav Idi bar Avin was a Rav.
Machlokes A&B.
Machlokes A&C.
Reuven and Shimon both claim that a field belonged to their respective parents, and Reuven brings witnesses to that effect, whereas Shimon brings witnesses that he had worked on it for three years who wins?
Reuven
Shimon.
They split.
Machlokes A&B.
Machlokes A&C.
Levi claimed Yehudah was on his land. Yehudah brought witnesses that he used it for two years. What must Yehudah pay?
Land.
Fruit.
Both.
Neither.
Machlokes B&C.
Can Yehudah now claim the land is a rental and keep the fruit?
Yes.
No. Not believed if he had originally claimed that.
No. Believed if he had originally claimed that.
Machlokes A&B.
Machlokes B&C.
If Reuven held a scythe and said 'I am going to reap Shimon's tree, I bought it from him', he is ________ .