Temurah Chart #4
Chart for Temurah Daf 17a
THE DIFFERENT TEXTS OF THE GEMARA: WHEN ONE MAKES A TEMURAH B'SHOGEG, IS HE PUNISHED WITH MALKUS, OR IS THE ANIMAL MERELY CONSECRATED AND HE IS EXEMPT?
| (A) THE TEXT OF OUR GEMARA, AND SHITAH MEKUBETZES (1) |
(B) THE TEXT OF KORBAN AHARON, TZON KODASHIM, AND VILNA GA'ON (2) |
(C) THE TEXT OF RASHI, AND RABEINU BARUCH (3) |
(D) THE TEXT OF RASH MI'SHANTZ (3) AND SHITAH MEKUBETZES (2) |
||
| 1 | HE THOUGHT IT WAS MUTAR TO MAKE TEMURAH |
Malkus | 1. Malkus 2. Kodesh (4) |
Malkus | Kodesh |
| 2 | HE INTENDED TO SAY "TEMURAS OLAH" BUT SAID "TEMURAS SHELAMIM" |
Kodesh | Kodesh | Malkus | Kodesh |
| 3 | HE WANTED TO SAY "BLACK" BUT SAID "WHITE" |
Malkus | Malkus | Malkus | Kodesh |
| 4 | HE THOUGHT HE WAS *EXCHANGING* KEDUSHAH, AND NOT *SPREADING* KEDUSHAH |
Malkus | Malkus | Malkus | --- (5) |
| 5 | HE INTENDED TO MAKE TEMURAH WITH INTENT, BUT ACTUALLY MADE IT WITHOUT INTENT |
Malkus | Malkus | Malkus | --- |
-------------------------------------------------
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) The Shitah Mekubetzes (#2) cites two texts of the Gemara.
(2) This is also the text of the Rambam.
(3) As quoted by Tosfos DH Gabei.
(4) The Gemara presents two versions at this point, according to this Girsa.
(5) It is not possible to say here that it is not Kodesh, as the Shitah Mekubetzes (#9) points out. Indeed, when the Shitah Mekubetzes (#2) cites this text, he makes no mention of either Malkus or Kadosh with regard to the latter two cases.