Kesuvos Chart #13
Chart for Kesuvos Daf 89a
THE ARGUMENT BETWEEN REBBI SHIMON AND THE RABANAN (87b) REGARDING WHEN A WOMAN MAKES A SHEVU'AH
| (A) DOES SHE MAKE A SHEVU'AH TO COLLECT KESUVAH |
(B) DOES SHE MAKE THE SHEVU'AH OF AN APOTROPOS |
(C) DOES SHE MAKE A SHEVU'AH TO COLLECT MEZONOS |
|||
| 1 | WHEN COLLECTING *IN ABSENCE* OF HER HUSBAND (R. Yirmeyah) |
||||
| 1a) | REBBI SHIMON | Swears | --- | Does not swear | |
| 1b) | RABANAN | Swears | --- | Swears | |
| 2 | SHEVU'AH OF AN APOTROPOS *OF YESOMIM* (Rav Sheshes) |
||||
| 2a) | REBBI SHIMON | Swears | Does not swear (1) | Does not swear | |
| 2b) | RABANAN | Swears | Swears | Does not swear | |
| 3 | SHEVU'AH OF AN APOTROPOS *OF HUSBAND* WHO RELEASED HER FROM ALL SHEVU'OS (Abaye) |
||||
| 3a) | REBBI SHIMON | Swears (2) | Does not swear (3) | Does not swear | |
| 3b) | RABANAN | Does not swear | Swears | Does not swear | |
-------------------------------------------------
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) Since the father of the Yesomim appointed her as Apotropos, she is exempt from making a Shevu'ah. This follows the ruling of Aba Shaul, who holds that if we make an Apotropos swear no one will agree to be appointed as an Apotropos and oversee the man's property.
(2) Rebbi Shimon holds like Aba Shaul ben Ima Miryam, that the father cannot exempt his wife from making a Shevu'ah when collecting the Kesuvah from the Yesomim. (See Insights to 88a.)
(3) Rebbi Shimon holds that the woman who becomes an Apotropos for her husband cannot be forced by her husband to make a Shevu'ah.