More Discussions for this daf
1. Havah Amina and Maskana of Shmuel 2. Korbanos Nazir
DAF DISCUSSIONS - ZEVACHIM 117

Moshe Reinitz asks:

Sholom Aleichem Rabbi Kornfeld and fellow Kollel Members:

In the charts on 117b the last chart talks about the 'Hava Amina' of Shmuel and the Maskana of Shmuel something is wrong or mixed up in the whole chart. Please check.

http://www.dafyomi.co.il/zevachim/hebcharts/zv-tl-117.htm.

Thank you,

Moshe Usher Reinitz

The Kollel replies:

Yes, Reb Mosher Usher, you are right! The boxes have got mixed up.

In the Hava Amina of Shmuel; in the box of Chatas and Asham it should have said what in fact it says in the Olah and Shelamim box; namely that there is a Machlokes; that according to R'Meir one brings these Korbanos but according to Rabanan one does not. In the Olah and Shelamim box it should have said what it does in fact say in the Chatas and Asham box; namely that everyone agrees that the korbanos are brought.

Again in the Maskana of Shmuel, what it says in the Chatas and Asham box should be switched with what it says in the Olah and Shelamim box and so vice versa also.

Apologies

Dovid Bloom